Offshore Drilling: The Show Must Go On

Via Politico: GOP Returns for Day 2 of Talkathon: apprently, the House GOP has returned to an empty House for a second day to protest Pelosi’ refusal to bring offshore drilling to a vote.

Hoping to ride on a populist wave, the GOP has seized the public’s support for expanded offshore drilling (as shown in polls), and tried to frame the Democratic Congress as a bunch of do-nothings that idly sit while average Americans are suffering record gas prices. The GOP’s rhetoric is that “something needs to be done” in order to show the public that Congress cares.

Let me just say this: “something needs to be done” is possibly one of the worst rationales for doing something. Just because the public is clamoring for something doesn’t mean that that “something” is a particularly good idea, especially for something as complicated as energy pricing in a global market.

Let’s examine why all this rah-rah about expanding offshore drilling is not likely to reduce gas prices for ordinary American consumers in the forseeable future. And in a twist, I am going to use the oil industry’s own words as the basis of my argument.

In a letter to Congress (PDF) written by Red Cavaney, President and CEO of the American Petroleum Institute (“the only national trade association that represents all aspects of America’s oil and natural gas industry“) on June 26, 2008, Cavaney writes:

“Crude oil prices remained above $130 a barrel last week, keeping the price of a gallon of crude oil – the raw material used to make gasoline, diesel, and other fuels – well above $3.00. Rising world demand, lagging growth in supply, and tight spare production capacity are the main drivers of these increases.”

If “rising world demand, lagging growth in supply, and tight spare production capacity” are the reasons the oil industry attributes to the rising cost of gas, then at most, expanding offshore drilling will address only one of them: namely, lagging growth in supply. By itself, expanding offshore drilling will not address increasing global demand or tight spare production capacity (i.e., lack of refineries).

Now, how will expanding offshore drilling resolve this issue? According to Mr. Cavaney:

“As a nation, we can have more control over our energy destiny by supplying more of the oil and natural gas we’ll be consuming from resources here at home. Government policy now stands in the way of that. However, polls show that a rising majority of Americans want expansion of access to federal oil and gas resources now off limits…”

Yet if “rising world (emphasis mine) demand” is one of the key drivers of rising gas prices, then an increase in supply only addresses world demand, not uniquely American demand. And this still does not address the other factor that Cavaney mentions–lack of spare production capacity.

Now, there is also the problem of timing: how long does it take to bring crude oil to market? According to Mr. Cavaney:

“And if a company is successful, years more are spent in the work required to bring the resources to market.”

So if it takes years to bring the crude oil to market, and you combine that with the lack of spare production capacity, you are looking at a very long time before the crude oil is brought to market, in order to meet a global demand, with no guarantee that the oil goes back into the American market.

And what does the oil industry hope to accomplish? Once again Mr. Cavaney comes to the rescue:

“…to enhance our nation’s energy security, create more American jobs, and keep more dollars at home in the American economy.”

Notice how none of those goals include REDUCING GAS PRICES for the ordinary American consumer–and after all, isn’t that what the political rhetoric is all about?

But should anyone be surprised that reducing gas prices for the ordinary American is not one of the oil industry’s objectives? Why should the industry want that? After all, Exxon-Mobile just reported the most profit earned in a quarter by any corporation, EVER.

So please, for the “concerned lawmakers” out there, save us the fucking rhetoric. Energy pricing in a global market is way too complicated for someone from Kansas alone to address. All this talk may play to the base, and God knows it’s an election year, but if the base is hopelessly retarded and knows nothing about how global economics work, then stop stooping to its stupidity.

Just because something can be done doesn’t mean that you should fucking do it.

But like Roger Waters once sang: the show must go on, so here’s to the circus act that is Congress in an election year.


One Response to “Offshore Drilling: The Show Must Go On”

  1. jeff roensch Says:

    The only energy or oil monopoly in this country is a governmental institutionalized monopoly on our country energy market. The legislative branch has been engaging in anti-competitive energy practices from drilling to building new refineries and much more. They are in clear violation of the

    “Sherman Antitrust Act
    This Act expresses our national commitment to a free market economy in which competition free from private and governmental restraints leads to the best results for consumers.”

    Clearly the governmental restraint are in violation of a free market economy and is criminal negligence on the part of the liberal politicians who are the real cartel that profit in taxes more then 3 to 1 to the oil companies that actually work for their money and then have to pay taxes on top of that. So when Oil profits go up the tax revenue increase is 3 times that of the oil companies. So who do you think is the real cartel???

    This criminal incompetence of the democrats and legislative politicians anti free market energy economy in allowing American companies to meet American Oil needs is in need of change and with bush opening up offshore drilling it is time that we conservatives take a page from the left wing play book and for us to us the judicial system in upholding our laws and open up drilling.

    Why dose the Senate call for investigations on big oil? Because they are trying to transfer the blame off of them by placing the blame on someone else. By placing the blame on the oil companies and keep people from seeing that government is the true problem they are able to offer false hope in an effort to gain more power and money from taxes while eliminating a free market economy in our country and forcing us to send our money to unfriendly Middle Eastern countries.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: